Flint Insurance, Simple
Flint Personal
Car Insurance
Home insurance
Flint Trades
Prestige Car Insurance
High Value Home Insurance
Flint Business
Motor Trade Insurance
HGV insurance
Flint Trades
Flint Trades
Employers Liability
Insurance
Professional Indemnity
Insurance
Customer Satisfaction In 2014 Flint Insurance surveyed existing customers to rate the overall standard of service they received from us, 98% of 3800 people surveyed rated Flint's services as extremely good.
It's nice to know we deliver a premium level of customer satisfaction to our clients, we work hard at Flint to make sure you get the insurance service you require for your everyday needs.
 
Insurance News

Insurance News, brought to you by Flint Insurance

 

Commercial Claims – Hot Work

Published: 22/08/2017

Commercial Claims – Hot Work

Jim Tuhey

For this issue's commercial claims Jim Tuhey wants to talk about three hot works case studies recently featured by Zurich, who are part of our commercial insurer panel.

Fires involving hot works may be rare, but when they occur, the damage to property is often substantial. Sparks can quickly spread to neighbouring buildings and cause fires that are hard to bring under control.

Investigations into the causes of hot work fires often find they could have been avoided if proper safety procedures had been observed.

Here, Stewart Powell and Graham Herridge, from Zurich’s Major Loss Team, discuss three significant claims we have handled recently, all relating to major fires during roofing work.

It's worth noting that all of these examples involve public buildings – the loss does not relate to a 'faceless corporation'. The inconvenience that these events cause to our over stretched schools is intolerable and ultimately it is the tax payer who will eventually bear the brunt of increased premiums because of bad practice.

Case study 1

This fire occurred during the school summer holidays. Plastic tarpaulin caught light as a gas torch was being used, and the fire spread rapidly, destroying much of the school. Subsequent investigations identified a number of failings that meant the risk of a fire occurring had not been adequately addressed.

Stewart says: “The biggest issue in this incident was that there was no hot work permit in place to ensure the works were being managed safely.

“In addition to that, materials were being stored on the roof where the works were taking place and there was no fire extinguisher on site.

“The absence of a fire extinguisher may have put the contractor in breach of their Hot Works Warranty, as their insurer refused to indemnify them following the loss.”

Case study 2

Hot work permits specify that for torch-applied roofing, a fire watch must remain in place for at least an hour after work has finished for the day, to ensure all sparks and embers in the site area have been extinguished.

Stewart says: “In this incident, we believe the contractor left the site before the one-hour fire watch period had elapsed, and it was during this time that a fire took hold. Had the contractor stayed on site, the damage could have been minimised considerably.

“Although there was a hot work permit in place on this occasion, it was the contractor’s permit, and nobody from the school had oversight of it.

“It may also have been possible for cold works to have been used instead, but no explanation was given as to why this option was not chosen.”

Case study 3

This fire occurred at a particularly sensitive time – as students were returning to school to collect their GCSE results.

Combustible materials caught light as maintenance work was taking place on the roof of a two-storey building that housed a library and IT facilities. Although the fire was spotted quickly, it spread so rapidly that the whole of the building was destroyed.

Graham says: “Although there was a hot work permit in place, managed by the contractor, it didn’t achieve a great deal and appeared to be more of a box-ticking exercise.

“One of the problems identified was that it was a generic permit for a larger programme of works taking place at the school; the permit wasn’t specifically created to manage the risks associated with hot works.

“In addition, there was no proper oversight of the permit. It was kept in the contractor’s cabin and the only person who saw it was the individual who had issued it.”

 

Learning lessons from hot works fires

Losses from fires involving hot works can sometimes run into millions of pounds. Indeed, in one recent claim Zurich handled, the loss was estimated at nearly £20m. Careful management of the associated risks is therefore essential.

Cunningham Lindsey, one of Zurich’s partner loss adjusters, has conducted a review into the causes of hot works fires, which found evidence of:

  • Inadequate or cursory work area inspections
  • A failure to properly brief those carrying out hot work on the nature of the works
  • Poor project oversight, including the way that subcontractors are managed

Following its review, Cunningham Lindsey has recommended that individuals responsible for authorising hot works ensure that:

  1. Less hazardous work methods have been considered.
  2. Project specific work and method statements have been compiled.
  3. Worker qualifications have been checked.
  4. A work area risk assessment has been conducted.
  5. Those carrying out the work have signed an authorisation to work as per the agreed method.
  6. Periodic inspections are carried out.
  7. A final check on the works area is made at the end of each working day.

 

Zurich has also produced guidance for Hot Work – which you can download here

 

 

 

 

News Archive »

RSS News Feed
To subscribe to our RSS feed click here »

View the complete range of our Commercial Insurance products »

Call me backCall Me Back
To find out more about any Flint Insurance product, or to get a quote: Request a call back » One of our advisors will call you back at a time to suit you.
 
Authorised and regulated by the Financial Services Authority
Goods in Transit Lorry Insurance Fleet Insurance Commercial Insurance Buy to let Insurance Engineering insurance
         
Flint Insurance Sitemap Contact us Insurance News Company Vision Claims Renewals About us